Skip to main content

Updated May 6, 2026

Best COI Tracking Software for Property Managers (2026)

Seven platforms compared by pricing, vendor capacity, AI capabilities, and what they're actually good at. We rank COIPulse first because we built it — but the rest of this list is honest about which competitor fits which situation. If your portfolio is bigger than 1,000 vendors and you want a human analyst team, we'll tell you to look at myCOI.

TL;DR — Pick by portfolio size

1

COIPulse Best overall

AI-first COI tracking with a free tier and trade-specific rules

Pricing: Free for 15 vendors → $49–$299/mo for paid tiers

Best for: Property managers with 15-500 vendors who want modern AI extraction without enterprise pricing.

Pros

  • AI extraction with 99.2% accuracy on certificates and endorsement forms
  • Trade-specific compliance rules (different requirements for plumbers vs roofers vs landscapers)
  • CG 20 10 / CG 20 37 endorsement form scoring built in
  • A.M. Best carrier rating lookup automated
  • Regression detection — alerts when renewed COIs have lower coverage than the previous term
  • Free tier for up to 15 vendors, no credit card required
  • Self-service onboarding (set up in 10 minutes, not 6 weeks)

Cons

  • Newer platform — not the right pick for Fortune-500 portfolios with 5,000+ vendors that need a dedicated account team
  • Managed services not included (we automate the work that those typically do)
  • Direct carrier API integrations limited to top US carriers

Free

$0/mo

Up to 15 vendors

Starter

$49/mo

Up to 50 vendors

Pro

$129/mo

Up to 200 vendors

Growth

$299/mo

Up to 500 vendors

Try COIPulse free — no credit card
2

TrustLayer

Automated Insurance Verification Platform

Pricing: $200-$500/month for starter tiers (estimated)

Best for: Mid-market commercial real estate teams that want a polished UI and direct carrier verification.

Pros

  • Strong tech-forward UI
  • Direct carrier API integrations
  • Workflow automation for approvals

Cons

  • Pricing 3–6x higher than COIPulse
  • No free tier
  • Heavier setup process
3

Jones (formerly Evident)

Insurance Verification & Risk Mitigation

Pricing: $2-$6 per vendor/month (estimated based on market data)

Best for: Large commercial REITs and construction firms with deep PMS integrations (MRI, Yardi, AppFolio).

Pros

  • Property management software integrations
  • Vendor outreach automation
  • Established enterprise customer base

Cons

  • Quote-based pricing — opaque
  • Setup typically 4-8 weeks
  • Annual contracts required
4

myCOI Central

Insurance Tracking & Compliance Management

Pricing: $3-$8 per vendor/month (estimated based on market reports)

Best for: Enterprise portfolios (1,000+ vendors) that want fully outsourced compliance with human analysts.

Pros

  • Dedicated insurance analyst team
  • Strong for very-large portfolios
  • High-touch managed service

Cons

  • Among the most expensive in the market ($10K-$50K+ annual)
  • Slower to act on certificate updates (human-in-the-loop)
  • Not cost-effective under 500 vendors
5

BCS (Business Credentialing Services)

Compliance Management for Vendor Risk

Pricing: $4-$10 per vendor/month (estimated for insurance-only tracking)

Best for: Energy, utilities, and manufacturing organizations that need vendor credentialing beyond just insurance (OSHA, safety training).

Pros

  • Comprehensive credentialing (insurance + safety + training + drug testing)
  • Strong industry coverage in energy/utilities
  • Compliance analyst services included

Cons

  • Overkill if you only need COI tracking
  • Per-vendor pricing scales aggressively at high vendor counts
  • Less property-management focused than other tools
6

CertFocus

Certificate of Insurance Tracking & Management

Pricing: $3-$7 per vendor/month (estimated)

Best for: Retail REITs and mid-market property management firms that want a managed-services model.

Pros

  • Managed certificate collection
  • Solid reporting dashboards
  • Deficiency follow-up service

Cons

  • Pricing not transparent
  • Older interface vs newer competitors
  • Limited modern features (AI extraction is partial)
7

SmartCompliance

Insurance Certificate Management & Compliance Automation

Pricing: $150-$300/month for base tier (estimated)

Best for: Mid-market property management firms wanting a flat monthly subscription with optional managed services.

Pros

  • Predictable flat pricing ($150-$300/mo base)
  • Optional managed services tier
  • Simpler than enterprise tools

Cons

  • Limited AI capabilities
  • Smaller integration ecosystem
  • Slower roadmap vs newer entrants

Frequently asked questions

What is COI tracking software?

Certificate of Insurance (COI) tracking software automates the process of collecting, verifying, and monitoring vendor insurance certificates. Property managers and contractors use it to ensure every vendor working on a property has valid general liability, workers compensation, and any required additional insured endorsements (commonly CG 20 10 and CG 20 37) before letting them on site. Without software, this is typically tracked in spreadsheets and consumes 10-15 hours per week per compliance manager.

What's the cheapest COI software for small property management firms?

COIPulse offers a free tier for up to 15 vendors and paid tiers starting at $49/month for 50 vendors. SmartCompliance and TrustLayer start at $150-$200/month. myCOI, Jones, BCS, and CertFocus use per-vendor pricing that's typically $3-$10 per vendor per month and require annual contracts.

How does AI extraction compare to manual data entry?

AI-based COI extraction (used by COIPulse and TrustLayer) reads PDF certificates and endorsement forms in seconds with 95-99% field-level accuracy. Manual data entry by analysts (used by myCOI and CertFocus) is more flexible for unusual certificate formats but takes hours to days per certificate and costs significantly more. For standard ACORD 25 certificates, AI extraction is faster and equally accurate.

What are CG 20 10 and CG 20 37?

CG 20 10 (Additional Insured – Owners, Lessees or Contractors – Scheduled Person Or Organization) covers ongoing operations. CG 20 37 (Additional Insured – Owners, Lessees or Contractors – Completed Operations) covers completed work. Most property managers require BOTH endorsements on vendor COIs to ensure coverage during AND after the work is done. Quality COI software automatically scores whether these endorsements are present and properly attached.

Should I use a managed service or self-service software?

Managed services (myCOI, CertFocus) make sense if you have 1,000+ vendors and want to fully outsource the compliance function. Self-service software (COIPulse, TrustLayer) makes sense if you have 50-1,000 vendors and want lower costs plus faster turnaround. The break-even is usually around 800-1,200 vendors — below that, self-service automation is more cost-effective; above it, the human-analyst model can pay for itself in caught-issues per year.

Do these platforms integrate with property management software (Yardi, AppFolio, MRI)?

Jones, BCS, and TrustLayer have established integrations with major PMS platforms. COIPulse offers REST API and webhook integrations (compatible with Zapier, Make.com, n8n) for any PMS. myCOI and SmartCompliance have limited PMS integrations and rely on CSV import/export.

Stop Tracking COIs in Spreadsheets

COIPulse automates vendor insurance compliance. AI-powered extraction, trade-specific rules, and automated reminders. Free for up to 20 vendors.